Substitutions

The more I research, shop, and question, the more information I find all the time about substitutes for many different foods -- below is just a sample.  If you are looking for substitutes for a particular food and you don't see it here, please tell me about it via the comment box below and I will be happy to help! 

Also check out my new Substitutions Guide available on Amazon.com at: http://www.amazon.com/Food-Allergies-Beyond-Substitutions-ebook/dp/B00A5GSVUK.

TO REPLACE: 
             
CRANBERRY    Fresh*:  lingonberry, currant, gooseberry, jujube berry (Chinese date, annab)
                             Dried*: raisin (dried grape), currant, goji berry, blueberry, jujube berry
                             (Chinese date, annab)

                             Substitutes with similar taste & texture when cooked: lingonberry, currant,
                             mayhaw (hawthorn berry), goji berry

                             Other substitutes* when cooked: cherry, blueberry, rhubarb, quince

EDIBLE FOOD-WRAPPERS (wheat-derived)  
                     ·      Edible leaves (cooked only): grape, fig (young leaves), cabbage, swiss chard, spinach, taro, Mexican chaya
              ·      soy-derived: soybean paper (mamenori), tofu/bean curd skins
              ·      rice paper/spring roll wrappers (cooked)
              ·      tapioca sheets (cooked)
              ·      prepared Chebe dough (commercial product, primarily manioc flour)
              ·      nori (seaweed)

GELATIN (animal-derived)   
              1½ tsp. gelatin powder = 1 tsp. agar powder or  Tbsp. agar flakes or                                                               ½ agar/kanten bar
(Note: any of these three will gel 1 c. liquid)

               1 T. gelatin = 2 c. liquid + 1 tsp. granulated agar (kanten) or  2 T. flaked agar (kanten)

                Other substitutes*:
                 ·   starch made from arrowroot, rice, corn, tapioca, water chestnut, sago, taro, kudzu
                 ·   guar gum, xanthan gum, agar (kanten)
                 ·   methylcellulose (vegetable-derived)
                 ·   egg
                 ·   carrageen (sea vegetable sold dried)

Note:  Although xanthan gum and guar gum are usually interchangeable in recipes, xanthan is derived from corn sugar bacteria whereas guar is plant-derived.  Neither should be over-consumed, as they could have a laxative effect.

POTATO (white)
·   Mashed:   boiled or steamed cassava (manioc, tapioca or yuca root), cauliflower, celeriac (celery root), or rutabaga  (swede) mixed with butter and cream or milk of any sort; can do same with yams or sweet potatoes if not allergens
·  Chunks:    chestnuts, water chestnuts, turnip, jicama, burdock root (gobo), salsify (scorzonera), Chinese potato (arrowhead, arrowroot tuber), celeriac (celery root),  lotus root, sweet potato, yam, rutabaga (swede), kohlrabi, Jerusalem artichoke (sunchoke), or whole Chinese artichokes (chorogi, crosnes), chayote (vegetable pear), arracacha (Peruvian white carrot, mandioquinha), breadfruit, bamboo shoots
·  Chips made from: taro root (dasheen), rutabaga (swede), yam, jicama, yuca root (cassava, manioc, tapioca), sweet potato, turnip, parsnip, malanga, kohlrabi, salsify (scorzonera), plantain, arracacha (Peruvian white carrot, mandioquinha), yacon tuber/root, rice, corn

                                     Note: Potato starch is made by extracting and refining the starch in the potato, whereas potato flour is dried, crushed potato; they behave differently in cooking, and potato flour has a distinctive potato flavor.

POTATO (sweet) -- Often known as "yam" in the USA.
Substitutes similar in taste & texture when cooked:
         camote (Mexican sweet potato, Japanese nagaimo), winter squash (butternut, acorn), cooked mashed persimmon, cherimoya, Mexican eggfruit (canistel, yellow sapote)

PUMPKIN, cooked
Substitutes similar in texture and color when cooked and mashed*:
                                   sweet potato (USA “yam”), winter squash (butternut, acorn), persimmon, mamey sapote

QUINCE
Fresh*: apple, pear, Asian pear (nashi)

Cooked*: persimmon, apple, pear, apricot, rhubarb, mayhaw (hawthorn berry), loquat, prickly pear (cactus fruit), fig, cranberry, guava

* Flavor may differ somewhat from original ingredient.

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

I would like to see replacement for eggs, but i have a few for you,
flax meal 1tsp + 2tbps warm water mixed up really well let set for 10 minutes and then mix and use as 1 egg up to 3 eggs for baking, i add cornstarch to mine so it works better.

however my daughter is allergic to poultry, eggs, tomatoes, potatoes, wheat, gluten, and milk. soon hopefully it'll go away but i know a few people allergic to almost everything you could possibly think of eating. :(

Anonymous said...

Thank you SO much for these substitutions! I am allergic to apple, corn, and onion and have NEVER been able to find substitutions for them!

Anonymous said...

What would be a good substitute butter in baking that is dairy free, soy free, coconut free, and nut free?

Bethany Niazian said...

I'm glad to be of help. I have a LONG list of substitutions that would take up too much space on this page to publish here, but if you have any other foods for which you're trying to find a substitute, just let me know :-)

Bethany Niazian said...

In baked goods, ½ c. butter =
• ½ c. lard, or vegetable/palm shortening
• ⅓ c. oil from canola (rapeseed), olive, rice bran, corn, safflower, or sunflower
• ⅓ c. thick prune puree (prune butter/lekvar) in low-fat chocolate or heavily spiced baked goods
• 1½ c. ground flax seed (flax meal); this is a 3:1 ratio of flax meal to butter or oil (Note: more rapid browning may occur when using this substitute)

For sautéing/frying, 1 c. + 2 T. butter =
• 1 c. vegetable oil
• 1 c. vegetable shortening (Crisco)
• 1 c. lard
• 1 c. bacon grease

Oil-derived “buttery spreads” are commercially available that are made from canola (rapeseed), palm, rice bran or olive.

Note: Some people who cannot consume cow’s milk – depending on whether they have an allergy or sensitivity to lactose (milk sugar) or casein/whey (milk protein) or are lacking sufficient lactase necessary to digest lactose – can still consume other dairy products made with cow’s milk, such as yogurt, cream, certain cheeses, butter and clarified butter (ghee). Furthermore, there are "buttery spreads" made from milk of other animmals which might not cause an allergic reaction like cow's milk does -- among the choices are those made from the milk of goat, sheep, water buffalo and yak.

Kate said...

I'd like to propose another .... some "healthier" recipes will use applesauce rather than oil for baked goods. I'm allergic to apples, so I have substituted mashed banana for the applesauce. Works well!

Bethany Niazian said...

Thanks, Kate -- you're absolutely right.

In fact, my newly published Substitutions Guide suggests lots of alternatives for oil/butter/shortening in baked goods and other recipes.

If you're interested, here's the link to its e-book form, which can be downloaded directly to your PC or to a Kindle tablet: http://www.amazon.com/Food-Allergies-Beyond-Substitutions-ebook/dp/B00A5GSVUK